Bishop stands firm on wheat exports

02 Oct, 2012 11:00 AM
Deputy Liberal leader Julie Bishop.
Deputy Liberal leader Julie Bishop.

DEPUTY Liberal leader Julie Bishop has hit back at accusations she is being disloyal to Western Australia by supporting the delay of full deregulation of the nation's $6 billion wheat export industry.

Ms Bishop insisted she had home town support for transitionary measures she believed the federal government was incapable of delivering.

"I'm a Liberal. We support deregulation but we want to do it in a way that sustains the industry," Ms Bishop told The Australian Financial Review from Perth on Monday. "I have no faith that [Agriculture Minister] Joe Ludwig will do it in a way that supports WA grain growers."

Complete deregulation of the wheat industry, which was recommended by the Productivity Commission in 2010, has ignited deep tensions within the federal Coalition.

It wants to defer any changes until after the next election, at the insistence of east-coast Nationals, who oppose deregulation.

Ms Bishop and West Australian senator Mathias Cormann have urged their WA colleagues to maintain a unified front and support Opposition Leader Tony Abbott. The pair drew a rebuke from senior party official Gordon Thomson, who questioned their loyalty to WA and said neither had "political nous or commonsense" on the issue, in a letter to party members last week.

Leader of the House Anthony Albanese said the government expected to put its Wheat Export Marketing Amendment Bill 2012 to a vote "between now and the end of the year".

"It really will be really interesting to see whether it is the case that [Nationals senator] Barnaby Joyce is writing the Coalition's economic policy," Mr Albanese said on Monday.

"So, Julie Bishop and other people in the west will have to decide whether they're actually prepared to do what they said they would do and back this reform."

Ms Bishop rejected suggestions she had done a backflip on her 2008 decision to support the industry's deregulation, which shifted to transitionary arrangements, including the formation of licensing body Wheat Exports Australia, which was supposed to be dissolved by the end of the year.

Some farmer groups are worried the nation's grain port and storage operators will be left with unfettered powers, while the bulk handlers argue regulation increases costs that are passed on to growers.

Ms Bishop said the government had not addressed the issues of full deregulation, including port access arrangements and wheat quality controls.

Liberal senators Alan Eggleston and Dean Smith are likely to cross the floor on the issue, while WA Nationals MP Tony Crook said he would back Labor's bill.

"I'm speaking on a daily basis with WA wheat growers," Ms Bishop said.

"Some are in Tony Crook's electorate. If he thinks Labor will look after his electorate he should talk to the growers who have contacted me."

The Australian Financial ReviewSource:
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


3/10/2012 9:56:43 AM

Disendorse Bishop. A Liberal who prefers regulation to deregulation belongs on the left of politics.
3/10/2012 1:26:28 PM

A party is judged by its actions not by internal politics. The average punter is not fooled by 'performances' that are supposed to reassure party politics are complex and complicated to manage. The fact this debate is even making the nightly news is laughable when you consider the average wheat producer who has voted like his grand daddy before him, will never change his vote. There simply is no votes in this industry for anyone. Growers discern who is fit to sell grain to. Its simple, if they are well capitalised then you will be paid for your wheat.
Farmer Joe
3/10/2012 8:17:20 PM

What has deregulation done for Australia. Allowed the Multi-national conglomerates to make money out of Australian grain growers. Aust. tax laws allow these profits to be repatriated without any tax paid. What a joke. Every Grain Trader should be required to be an Australian Registered Coy, abiding by Australian Coy Tax Laws. That iis 30% on all profits to the ATO. AWB was an Australian Coy paying Aust. Tax.. Australian farmers are being plunderes by the Vicking Muli Nationals.
Roger Crook
4/10/2012 1:54:54 PM

according to the poll in this paper 49% say yes to completing the process of deregulation and 52.4% have voted no. The last coalition govt started the process after the AWB bribe scandal. Now it seems that it is the Nats over east are against completing the process and have held a gun to the head of the Libs, presumably threatening the unity of the coalition in opposition. Yet, to complete the process of apparent chaos in the wheat industry yet again, the Nats in WA support the govt, as does Tony Crook, who is an Independent Nat, whatever that means? Can the WA Nats please explain?
Bushie Bill
9/10/2012 4:11:46 PM

It has made us a much more competitive and efficient, Farmer Joe, or more accurately, it has sorted out the competitive and efficient operators from the economically fat and lazy ones. Incidentally, your understanding of taxation is as abysmal as your understanding of economics.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
Excellent question aa, considering 90%+ is bought by china, why the Europe focus? Taking claim
light grey arrow
I'm always amused when the CEO of a mob like AWI offers "The levy is matched by federal
light grey arrow
Dept of Ag didn't bust Depp-it was the dog groomer or the like that "dobbed" the dogs in! As per